American Nightmare: Series Review

American Nightmare: Truth is Stranger Than Fiction

Watch this show right now:

We are avid fans of "Gone Girl," both the novel and its film adaptation. So, when we discovered that Netflix had just dropped a true crime documentary series titled "American Nightmare," inspired by a real-life "Gone Girl" case, we couldn't pass up the opportunity. What unfolded surpassed our expectations—a tightly woven, well-structured short series that adeptly captured the raw emotions of the victims.

Set in Mare Island, California, the story begins with Aaron Quinn reporting a home invasion and the kidnapping of his girlfriend, Denise Huskins. As the police dismiss his account as implausible, Aaron finds himself the prime suspect in Denise's presumed murder. The narrative takes a shocking turn when Denise reappears unharmed after two days. Yet, instead of relief, the couple faces accusations of orchestrating the entire ordeal, jeopardizing their lives in the process.

"Truth is stranger than fiction," and "American Nightmare" unveils a chilling reality—one that exposes the shortcomings of a police force, the FBI, and the media, all too quick to judge victims based on the perceived incredibility of their stories rather than scrutinizing the tangible evidence at hand. This theme resonates profoundly, even for us non-Americans, drawing parallels to police and investigative incompetence and quick judgement of the media and public in the Philippines. What sets "American Nightmare" apart from the typical true crime offerings on Netflix is its exceptional structure and knowing when to conclude. With just three episodes, the series is accessible and purposeful. Each episode serves a distinct role in providing firsthand context to the "Gone Girl" case. However, we must acknowledge that the feminist twist introduced towards the series' end felt somewhat forced and unnecessary in our opinion. Despite this minor critique, "American Nightmare" goes beyond expectations, offering a captivating exploration of the Mare Island case. If you're looking to scratch that true crime itch over a weekend, this series is a compelling and worthwhile choice.

Rating: 4 reels

Post a Comment